Insurance Institute Says Driver Assistance Systems Have Safety Concerns
【Summary】A study by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) finds level 2 driver assistance technologies aren’t as safe as claimed.
These days, almost every new vehicle has a driver assistance system. Even bargain-priced, entry-level econoboxes have features like adaptive cruise control, and lane keep assist. Since these technologies are everywhere, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) thought it would be a good idea to test them. And what the organization found wasn't pretty.
The IIHS analyzed five vehicles: a 2017 BMW 5-Series, 2017 Mercedes-Benz E-Class, 2018 Volvo S90, 2016 Tesla Model S and a Tesla Model 3. Each car was equipped with its brand of level 2 autonomous drive assistance technology. At grade two, vehicles have adaptive cruise control and lane keep assist, which is what the Institute tested.
In its paper, entitled "Reality Check" the IIHS divulged its findings.
On a closed course, most of the vehicles behaved themselves, except for the Tesla cars. Both the Model S and Model 3 hit a stationary balloon at 31 miles per hour, with adaptive cruise control turned off and automatic braking on. To be fair, the cars did much better with cruise turned on and were able to avoid the helium-filled inflatables.
When the vehicles moved out onto real-world roads things got even worse. All of the cars, except the Model 3, failed to respond to vehicles stopped ahead of them. And even the little Tesla had issues – it was overly cautious.
"In 180 miles, the car (Tesla Model 3) unexpectedly slowed down 12 times, seven of which coincided with tree shadows on the road," the IIHS report recounts. "The others were for oncoming vehicles in another lane or vehicles crossing the road far ahead."
Oops. Such braking isn't dangerous, of course, but it is irritating.
Problems also ensued when it came time to test the vehicles lane keep assistance systems. At one time or another, each of the cars had a hard time "keeping it between the lines".
Of course, level 2 autonomy is designed to help drivers, not replace them. The vehicles owner's manuals spell that out explicitly. So if a Tesla Model 3, fails to stop and hits a balloon, who's really to blame? The car and its electronics, or the person who didn't read their owner's manual?
Mia is an ASE Certified Master Automobile Technician, L1, L2 and L3 Advanced Level Specialist. She has over 12 years of experience in the automotive industry and a bachelor’s degree in automotive technology. These skills have been applied toward content writing, technical writing, inspections, consulting, automotive software engineering.
Tesla Model S Wagon Displayed in Geneva
Audi Reveals its Q4 e-tron Concept at the Geneva Motor Show
Goodyear Showcases Concept Tire for Flying Cars; 1950's Autonomous Vehicle
Kia to Premier Euro-spec Electric e-Soul at the Geneva Motor Show
Ford Developing Electric Mustang Crossover That CEO Says Will “Go Like Hell”
BMW to Premiere New Plug-in Hybrid Vehicles & Free EV Charging in Geneva
Honda Says EVs, Not Brexit, to Blame for Honda Plant Shutdown
EVgo Charging Network Powers 88% More EVs Than Last Year
- Startup Innolith Claims to Have EV Battery Capable of 600 Miles of Range
- Ahead of the e-tron Launch, Audi Launches Ad Campaign to Clarify Misconceptions About EVs
- Volvo & NVIDIA Announce a New Partnership to Develop Autonomous Vehicles
- Tesla CEO Elon Musk and the SEC Ask for More Time to Reach Deal Over Musk’s Use of Twitter
- Ford Confirms a Performance Version of the New Mustang-inspired Electric SUV
- U.S. Lawmakers Are Supporting a Electric Vehicle Supply Chain Policy to Help Secure Raw Materials for EV Batteries
- Zomato Tests Drones for Food Deliveries in India
- Tesla Continues to Outsell Competitors, Sees Strong Demand for Model 3
- Mini Cautiously Approaching an Electric Future
- BMW and Jaguar Land Rover Collaborate on Electric Vehicles